probably because beyonce talks intimately about songs she did nt even write.

she did not write any of I were a boy check out BCjean who wrote the song and beyonce takes credit for it....that weird, and just incredibly dishonest. OF course alicia keyes is nt gonna stand up in honour of someone that does nt even write their own music yet claims to.

check out BCjean on the net 16 year old singing sensation that actually wrote and performed this song.

true

you are talkin out of your ***

Beyonce didn't take credit. It was a rumour that Beyonce claimed the song when she didn't. Did you buy Beyonce's album?

If you did then look at the booklet and read under If I were a boy section. It says the writers are toby gad and BC Jean. She didn't write Beyonce.

haters are trying to pick on Beyonce but she will always be number 1

She was clapping----I think people want to make something out of nothing.

bey0nce's perf0rmance was the best at the AMAs. alicia keys 0h g0sh an0ther jeal0us c0mpetitive bitch just like rihanna. BEY0NCE IS NUMBER 1

beyonce should get a writing credit on a song becuz she changed a "period" to an "exclamation point." Why go on interviews and talk about a song like you wrote the whole darn thing yourself...its just weird and lacks conscience . kinda like wearing fur not thinking about what suffered before you put it on.

alcica keys aint o bitch u fukkin ediot dnt talk wot u dnt no cah i guarantee if u saw he ul b askin her 4 her autograph n beiing frend wiv her os shut da fuk up u prick